Raphael Varane Or Ruben Dias? Who is a better player?

An active and strong defence mechanism in any team forms a hard wall that protects the team on the field and this can only be done when passionate and dedicated players step in for this important role. In the history of Football, we have witnessed a lot of players dominating for a very long time and also becoming a sensation for the new generation. Two players with the same level of popularity and love from the fans will be compared in this article based on their performances at club and international levels to find out who is a better player also we will be taking a look at their team and individual titles to move to a clear conclusion.

Ruben Dias is a Portuguese professional footballer who plays as a centre-back for the Premier League club Manchester City and also for the Portugal national team. He is currently counted among the best in the field and is known for his defensive prowess and aerial abilities. He started his career in Benfica’s Youth Academy and got promoted to the Senior division in 2017. In the earlier days of his life, he was not under any professional guidance and used to play on the streets or inside his house with his younger brother Ivan.

Raphael Xavier Varane is a French footballer who plays as a center-back for the Premier League club Manchester United is considered one of the finest defenders in this era and is widely appreciated for his defensive prowess and speed. Born in the city of Lille, he began his career at the local club AS Hellemmes when he was 7 years old. Varane was a very rapidly growing player in his youth days as he earned deserving spots in his youth career very quickly.

1: Personal Career

Varane was given a chance in the senior team after the arrival of the new manager in Lens. The young player gave his best debut to the team and was also named to the starting lineup. He played the complete match and also won which earned him a lot of respect and appreciation for his performance in the very first days of his career. Even after the arrival of a new manager he retained his position in the starting lineup and continued to do well.

After a good spell with Lens, it was confirmed by the Real Madrid president that his joining in club. He appeared as a half-time substitute in the very first match and he finished the pre-season campaign with a total of 8 matches played with the club. Real Madrid won against Rayo Vallecano by a dominating score of 6-2 and Varane’s goal created history as he became the youngest foreign player at the age of 18 years to score a goal in a competitive match for Real Madrid. 

In the next season, he proved himself as one of the most important assets of the team as he performed exceptionally well defending some crucial goals and in the same season he again created history by becoming the second youngest foreign player to score for the club in a Clasico match. He was also named as one of the most performing foreign players in Real Madrid’s history. Varane also won the 2015-16 UEFA Champions League.

In the next season, he suffered a few injuries but still managed to appear a total of 23 times as the club won the La Liga title and also the UEFA Champions League. After an excellent and astonishing spell at Real Madrid, he was announced as the latest addition to the Manchester United lineup and was warmly welcomed by the fans and the club.

Ruben Dias was shown the way to the local club Estrela da Amadora by his relative and this is where he started his journey. He was moved to the Benfica youth academy where he was trained to be a midfielder until he was deployed as a center-back in the junior team. He performed exceptionally well on the junior side and helped the team bag the 4th position in the first season and also reached the final of the 2016-17 UEFA Youth League.

After making his debut in the senior team in 2017, he became one of the best players for the club and was also awarded the Primeira Liga’s Best Young Player of the Year. At the end of the season, the manager revealed that this would be his last season with Benfica and he would be departing soon. 

The young centre-back joined the English club Manchester City at a fee of 68 million euros on a 6-year deal and made his debut with the club in October 2020 against Leeds United in a 1-1 draw. On 15 September 2021, he also captained Manchester City for the very first time providing an assist in a 6-3 Champions League win.

In March 2022 it was announced that he had suffered a hamstring injury due to which he wouldn’t be playing for the next 2 months. This 2-month gap ruled him out of the Manchester Derby of the season and also the Portugal qualification playoff for the 2022 FIFA World Cup. In 2022-23 he started and played almost every minute of the campaign winning the Champions League trophy and completing a continental treble.

Dias and Raphael both players are exceptionally well and have been performing for a very long time but there is a difference of 4 years between the players and to be fair we must consider their best stats to find out who has been a better player throughout.

 VaraneDias
Games3233
Goals22
Assists13

Dias has played fewer matches as compared to Varane but still, he managed to score the same number of goals and two more assists as compared to Varane which is enough to prove Dias is a better opponent in this comparison. 

2: Titles

Trophies are the most important when carrying out a detailed comparison of two football players. We know that both players we are covering in this article have been consistent throughout their careers despite the many lows they have faced. So, we will have a look at the number of titles they have won to see their contribution to the team.

VaraneDias
4x Champions League1x Champions League
3x Supercup1x Supercup
3x La Liga3x Premier League
1x Copa Del Rey1x FA Cup
4x FIFA CWC1x Primeira League
3x Supercopa de Espana1x Supertaça
1x EFL Cup1x EFL Cup

Based on the numbers above it is evident that Varane has more trophies under his belt and has lifted a lot more trophies compared to Dias. 

3: Individual Honors

A comparison is always incomplete without the individual honours that the players have earned. However, winning honours cannot be considered as a superiority in the spot but can be taken into consideration as a mark of dedication and proving their worth for the team.

Individual Honors Of Ruben Dias:

Cosme Damião Awards – Revelation of the Year: 2017

Primeira Liga Best Young Player of the Year: 2017–18

UEFA Nations League Finals Team of the Tournament: 2019

Primeira Liga Defender of the Month: March 2018, October/November 2019

Primeira Liga Team of the Year: 2019–20

FWA Footballer of the Year: 2020–21

PFA Team of the Year: 2020–21 Premier League,2022–23 Premier League

Manchester City Player of the Year: 2020–21

UEFA Champions League Squad/Team of the Season: 2020–21,

Premier League Player of the Season: 2020–21

ESM Team of the Year: 2020–21

UEFA Champions League Defender of the Season: 2020–21

IFFHS Men’s World Team: 2021

FIFA FIFPro World11: 2021

Individual Honors Of Raphael Varane:

FIFA FIFPro World XI

UEFA Team of the Year

UEFA Squad of the Season

FIFA World Cup Fantasy Team

FIFA World Cup Dream Team

IFFHS Men’s World Team

Ruben Dias and Varane are loved by many and are highly popular for their defence. But in this segment, the best is to be chosen and Ruben Dias is clearly ahead of Ruben Dias.

4: International Career

Dias represented the under-17 Portugal National team in the 2014 Under-17 European Championship. He also captained the under-20 team and made his debut for the under-21 in the 2019 European under-21 Championship qualification match. After performing consistently when contributing majorly in the previous levels he was called up for the senior team in 2018 for friendly matches. He was also named for the 2018 FIFA World Cup squad. He established himself as one of the most important assets of the international team over time and was featured in all of Portugal’s matches in the 2019 UEFA Nations League and also helped the team reach the finals.

Dias was selected in the Portugal Squad for UEFA Euro 2020 and was named in the 2022 FIFA World Cup preliminary Squad. He earned his 50th cap in the UEFA Euro 2024 qualifier match against Luxembourg.

 

Varane youth career can be considered a very prolific career due to his astonishing performance and contributed majorly in the crucial qualifiers. He was called up for the senior team in 2012 against Uruguay as an unused substitute and was also given a chance in the 2014 World Cup qualifiers held in 2013 and was included in the 2014 World Cup Squad. He majorly contributed to the International team and has been consistently performing as a strong defence mechanism for the national team.

 VaraneDias
Games9351
Goals12
Assists50

We can see that Varane wins in this category as well and also has a far better International Career. Dias may be an asset for Portugal but it takes a lot more to edge a World Cup winner. However, we must not forget the fact that Dias is younger than Varane and has played international matches, but since this is a comparison we can clearly see Varane winning. 

5: Personal Life

Talking about Ruben Dias, he has dated singer April Ivy from 2018 to 2021 but they’re no longer together. He belongs to my family where his younger brother also plays football and his mom and dad always wanted him to be a footballer and become a successful person in this field and now they are super proud of what he has done in his life. His net worth is around 40 million dollars.

Varane is married to his long-time love Camille Tytgat and are parents of an adorable son Ruben and a daughter Anais. He has also expressed his love for singing and loves spending time with his son and daughter. We can say that he belongs to Sporting background as his brother Jonathan is also a professional footballer and his sisters have also competed in Miss France 2019. The net worth of Varane is around $20 million.

Raphael Varane Vs Ruben Dias? Who is the dominant player?

It is a very complex comparison between these players as both players can be seen giving tough competition to each other in all the categories. Based on the comparison above Varane was better in a few areas while Dias also has great achievements linked to his name. However, if we consider these factors both players have been performing exceptionally well and prove themselves as one of the most important assets of the team. 

Based on the comparison above we can conclude Varane is a slightly better player than Dias because of a better experience on the field and the situations that he has encountered along with the glories he has witnessed.

Subscribe
Notify of

0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments